| Winner | Runner-up | |
| 2022 | Alice Schilling | |
| 2021 | Nancy Kelly | |
| 2020 | Sally Schaffer | |
| 2019 | Karen Binder | |
| 2018 | Cindy Bischoff | |
| 2017 | Janie Miller | |
| 2016 | Janie Miller | |
| 2015 | Carole Hoffman | |
| 2014 | Carole Hoffman | |
| 2013 | Mimi Henderson | |
| 2012 | Mimi Henderson | |
| 2011 | Barbara Funnell | |
| 2010 | Cookie Ellis | |
| 2009 | Kathy Gallo | |
| 2008 | Cookie Ellis | |
| 2007 | Cheryl Hornberger | |
| 2006 | Mary Jane Park | |
| 2005 | Lennie Macarthur | |
| 2004 | Eileen Britt | |
| 2003 | Vi Theroux | |
| 2002 | Nancy Weller | |
| 2001 | Kathy Gallo | overall winners) |
| 2000 | Ginny Kelley | (Format changed to |
| 1999 | Mimi Henderson | Dottie Kuhlman |
| 1998 | Dottie Kuhlman | Barbara Muther |
| 1997 | Dottie Kuhlman | Mary Jane Park |
| 1996 | Dottie Kuhlman | Mary Jane Park |
| 1995 | Norma Diehl | Ellie Gochenaur |
| 1994 | Vi Theroux | Edyth Keyler |
| 1993 | Margaret Perino | Toni Marsden |
| 1992 | Jessie Meek | Norma Diehl |
| 1991 | Peg Lyons | |
| 1990 | Mary Jane Maloney | Barbara Burr |
| 1989 | Opal Reid | Ruth Kokes |
| 1988 | Jinx Walcott | Ann Ciampa |
| 1988 | Pearl Corns | Ruth Towers |
| 1987 | Barbara Post | |
| 1986 | Mary White | |
| 1985 | Sunny Leet | Mary Jane Maloney |
| 1984 | Pearl Corns | Mary Lou Brightman |
| 1983 | Mary Jane Maloney | Pearl Corns |
| 1982 | Ann Ciampa | Pearl Corns |
| 1981 | Pearl Corns | Ann Ciampa |
| 1980 | Ann Murphey | Opal Reid |
| 1979 | Alice Jenkins | Marjorie Ketchum |
| 1978 | Dottie Kuhlman | Ann Ciampa |
| 1977 | Barbara Swain | Edyth Keyler |
| 1976 | Eleanor Cameron | Ethel Hedstrom |
| 1975 | Helen Conold | Audrey Herbertson |
| 1974 | Audrey Herbertson | Jane Alwyn |
| 1973 | Barbara Anderson | Beavan Whitlock |
| 1972 | Marcia Lemnitzer | Betty Fay |
| 1971 | Katie Mendel | Jan Dean |
| 1970 | Helen Conold | Lu Seaton |
| 1969 | Helen Conold | Laura Hollister |
